Sssounds mean at first, to criticize a man for the way he talkssths. But speaking of mean, it would be irresponsible not to mention that Rudy Giuliani has a mean lisp. If you have watched the recent Republican primary debates, the former Mayor of New York has a very clear speech impediment. Iss that really important?
Perhaps. Can you imagine a rousing State of the Union address followed by “God Besss you all, and God Blessths America!” Rudy’s apparent misfortune may impede his ability to communicate in the Reaganesque style that all the republican candidates have been trying to capture. If Ronald Reagan were alive today though, Mr. Giuliani would be working on a more even playing field; namely in that every republican primary candidate has been kissing the great patriarch’s rear-end so fervently that their chapped lips would impair their pronunciation of the letter “s” as well.
To be honest, I do not really think it is Mr. Giuliani’s speech impediment that has been contributing to his confusing message. Its mostly his intricate mosaic of liberal and conservative views that seemed to have fused together as “America’s Mayor” began considering a run for The White House. Nothing burns my republican blood quite the same as the prospect of America’s first pro-abortion, anti-second amendment, opponent of illegal immigration enforcement, republican president.
Despite his recent attempts to appear interested in immigration reform, as mayor, Guliani thumbed his nose at the U.S. Supreme court when it ruled he was wrong in preventing N.Y. City employees from reporting illegal immigrants to the INS. In 1996, Giuliani said the “anti-immigration movement in America is one of our most serious public problems”. You might want to read that statement twice to take in the full meaning. If Mr. Giuliani meant that just legal immigration is desirable, I have no problem with that. But, if Rudy is in his heart of hearts a supporter of illegal immigration, I doubt he will demonstrate the necessary strength to bring about real immigration reform if elected President. We desperately need meaningful immigration reform; reform that will include a complete securing of our southern border, and the moderation of both the “push” and “pull” factors that entice millions of Mexicans to enter our country illegally each year.
To be fair, Giuliani has shown strong leadership qualities post 9/11. He is serious about national safety. He is fiscally conservative, and claims judicial conservatism- though he nominated mostly liberals to the bench when serving as mayor of N.Y.C. Despite his support of special rights for those involved in homosexuality, Giuliani does believe that traditional marriage should be preserved as the union of a man and a woman. He has a good sense of humor, and is decently charismatic.
All things taken together, Rudy Giuliani does not seem to be a real bad candidate for President when compared to democratic front runner Hillary Clinton, but neither is he a real good one if you are a supporter of conservative ideals. If we were to roll back the clock and pit Giuliani against John F. Kennedy, Kennedy would come out as the truer conservative.
One quality that made Ronald Reagan an effective speaker was his candid belief that “people respond to the truth.” If we want a public that will respond to our candidate, we may do better with increasingly popular Mitt Romney. Romney’s optomistic picture of America’s future includes capitalizing fully on emerging Asian markets, restoring family life as the center of American endeavor, and developing a comprehensive strategy for dealing with Iran. Romney’s recent statement about fellow Latter-day Saint Harry Reid was both Reaganesque and an intelligent piece of communication in its own right. Speaking of Reid’s recent “We have lost the war…” speech, Romney aptly quipped that if Reid “had been [at] Valley Forge, he’d have thrown in the white towel and we’d be singing as our national anthem “God Save the Queen.” -Now there’s an inconvenient truth!
Whoever the candidate for the GOP, America is in need of the kind of strong, optimistic, conservative leadership that only a proud Republican can provide. May “God Bless America” in 2008!- Even if that blessing comes in a sissomewhat diluted form, by the name of Rudolph Giuliani. I’m hoping for more!
While I am not sure how much Rudy Giuliani’s speech impediment bothers me, I am very concerned with his not-so-conservative views. In the world we live in today we desperately need a strong conservative leader. Giuliani has the strong part down, he proved to be a great leader in NY during 911. He seems to really be able to pull it out when times are tough. What I am more concerned about are his social views. He has been twice divorced, had two public affairs and defends abortion.
I think that John has it right. Giuliani is only half conservative. But I would take half conservative over insanely liberal.
-Daily Snack Fan
By: gop4ever on June 25, 2007
at 12:18 am
I think Giuliani is one of the smartest/ most capable candidates in either party. He possesses leadership ability, devotion, and has proved himself capable of turning around a monstrous city; not to say New York is the model for the rest of the nation. He has done a great job with the city though. However, as far as being a conservative candidate he is a total sellout to the political left. He’s a New York Republican, that’s for sure. Like John, I definitely favor Mitt Romney who, besides being more conservative, possesses more leadership, charisma, and managerial ability. Guiliani is number 2 in my book of all the big name candidates.
By: Louie Branson on June 25, 2007
at 2:21 am
Giuliani might not be the strongest candidate to run for the American Presidency but he will steal votes from Hillary Clinton in the NE which could actually get the Republicans in office next term. He is also mainstream and people know him nationwide because of 9/11.
Running for President is a popularity contest and to win you must appeal to the largest audience to win. Giuliani may or may not be the best man for the job, but because he can potentially swing the vote in the NE I think he has the best chance of winning among the current Republican candidates.
Personally, I am voting for the Green Party candidate again. Calm down John – just kidding.
By: Silence DoGood on July 17, 2007
at 12:11 am